Fencing Guild Sources
Page language · English

Themes › Afterblow and double hits

Afterblow and double hits

What happens when the fencer who was hit still manages to strike back, or when both hit at once: how many steps or how much time he has, whose hit counts, and who holds the privilege of the last blow.

What the comparison shows

In Lille (P015) the fencer who was hit has one step for his afterblow; a blow returned only after two steps does not count. Toulouse 1696 (P121) measures not by steps but by time: a hit followed by the other man's hit is counted for both up to two each, a simultaneous hit is replayed and a hit after a pause no longer counts. The Paris statutes of 1633 and 1644 (P026, P027) void a simultaneous hit in the master's examination and the exchange begins again. The London masters (P077) protect the candidate's answer differently: whoever strikes and then closes so that the candidate cannot strike back wins no point.

Strasbourg around 1470 (P006) and Hamburg 1671 (P257) forbid any blow after the bout has been stopped.

Manciolino's Italian treatise of 1531 (P078) reverses the order of merit: the one who hits with a response after receiving a blow is more praiseworthy than the one who hit first, but there is only one response, with one step forward. Mechelen (P066, art. IX) remains outside the table: there the afterblow is expressly the king's privilege, limited to three steps – we do not yet have the original wording of the article.

19 passages from 8 towns, 1470–1783. Sorted by year. A “rule” is what the text orders or forbids; “recorded practice” is what it records as an event or a claim. The summaries are working summaries; the original wording behind the link decides.

  1. 1470Strasbourg

    After a hit, once the staff has been placed between the fencers, no one may deliver any blow.

    P006 · § 8 rule edition read

    stange noch dem Rüre zweischen síe stosset oder leyt so sol keyner keyn streich zůtůn sol nit geben
  2. 1531Venice

    In play, the one who hits with a response after receiving a blow is more praiseworthy than the one who hits first.

    P078 · pravidlo 40 rule edition read

    è piu lodeuole chi ferisse di risposta
  3. 1531Venice

    After a received blow only one response with one step forward is allowed; with it honour can be recovered.

    P078 · pravidlo 41 rule edition read

    Non è lecito dopoi il receuuto colpo far piu di una risposta scorrendo innanzi con un uarco
  4. 1540London

    At any prize, whoever strikes his blow and closes so that the prizor cannot strike back wins no point, even if he breaks the prizor's head.

    P077 · poriadok o nákladoch, odsek 3 rule edition read

    doth strike his blowe and close withall so that the prizor cannot strike his blow after agayne, shall wynn no game
  5. 1544Königsberg

    When the wardens of the lists thrust their staffs between the fencers, no one may strike over them.

    P396 · proklamácia rule edition read

    wenn die Grieswärtel (Aufseher des Kampfplatzes) die Stangen unterschießen, darüberschlagen
  6. after 1589Lille

    If the fallen defender finds a way to return a valid hit to his opponent, that hit is deemed a double hit (coup fourré).

    P013 · pád obrancu na zem (obojstranný zásah) rule edition read

    trouvant moyen de rendre touche vaillable à sa partie, et lors sera ladite touche réputée pour coup fourré
  7. after 1589Lille

    After receiving a hit one has only one step; if the blow is not returned at the first step and two are taken, the blow is not held valid.

    P015 · pravidlo jedného kroku rule edition read

    que l'on n'a qu'un pas, après avoir reçu le coup
  8. 1633Paris

    If, in the trial, the hits are given at the same time, they count as void and the bout begins again.

    P026 · čl. 6 (skúška a obojstranný zásah) rule edition read

    lon a donné de mesme temps cela sera conté nul et recommenceront
  9. 1644Paris

    If in the trial both men hit at the same time, it counts as void for both sides and the bout is begun again.

    P027 · čl. 10 rule edition read

    on se donne tous deux de mesme temps, cela sera compté pour nul de part & d'autre & sera recommencé
  10. 1647Lille

    If the defender returns a cut with no other hit on either side, that cut is void and the attacker keeps the attempt as before.

    P018 · poznámka z 12. 5. 1647: sečný úder obrancu rule edition read

    au cas advenant qu'il rendrait coup d'estramason, sans autre touche de part et d'aultre
  11. 1671Hamburg

    The complaints record that fencers delivered a forbidden afterblow even after the bout had been stopped (Schuß gehalten).

    P257 · Sťažnosti recorded practice text read

    wann schon Schuß gehalten, verbotener Weise einigen Nachschlag gethan
  12. 1671Hamburg

    Fencers are not permitted to deliver any afterblow (Nachschlag) once the bout has been stopped.

    P257 · Zákazy a trest rule text read

    nachdem bereits Schuß gehalten, keinen Nachschlag zu thun befugt seyn
  13. 1696Toulouse

    A hit by one and then a hit by the other are counted up to two each.

    P121 · čl. 8 rule edition read

    Coup de l'un, & coup aprés de l'autre, sont comptez jusqu'à deux à deux
  14. 1696Toulouse

    Hits following without a pause, whether by renewed attack or riposte, are counted up to two and no more.

    P121 · čl. 9 rule edition read

    comptez jusqu'à deux bottes & sans plus, soit par reprise ou risposte
  15. 1696Toulouse

    A double hit or hit at the same time is replayed; if a man is found to have aimed at equal hits, the other's hit is counted, not his.

    P121 · čl. 10 rule edition read

    Coup fourré ou même-tems est à refere, à moins qu'on connut qu'un homme s'y attachoit pour faire les coups égaux
  16. 1696Toulouse

    Whoever hits, retires and claims the hit is not to be followed; if he claimed it wrongly, the other may thrust and all hits count up to two.

    P121 · čl. 15 rule edition read

    Celui qui donnera un coup, & se retirera en le demandant, ne doit point être suivi
  17. 1783Toulouse

    The capitouls saw most pupils, under the pretext of time hits, set off together and hit each other without judgement or precision – a brutal fight rather than a bout.

    P214 · čl. XXI recorded practice original checked

    nous avons vu la plûpart des éléves en faire leur seule ressource
  18. 1783Toulouse

    An imprecise so-called time hit is void; if the fencer who made it is himself hit, the hit is awarded to his opponent.

    P214 · čl. XXI rule original checked

    le coup sera jugé en faveur de son adversaire
  19. 1783Toulouse

    A fencer who keeps relying on such time hits during a bout is excluded on the spot and his rival wins; those who fence only so in the schools are not admitted.

    P214 · čl. XXI rule original checked

    il sera exclus sur le champ & son émule gagnera l’assaut