Fencing Guild Sources
Page language · English

Themes › Forbidden techniques

Forbidden techniques

What was not allowed in play: thrusts, pommel strikes, wrestling, breaking limbs, attacks on the eyes and groin, sharp weapons.

What the comparison shows

Lists naming the forbidden moves survive from Wrocław (P134 of 1614, P114 of 1615): cutting at the legs, pommel strikes, throwing down and striking over the staff. The Augsburg ordinance (P046) punishes seizing the opponent's weapon and striking him with a year's ban from the school and forbids ‘dishonest pieces’ in general. In Lille (P013) blows with the pommel and cross-guard are not forbidden, they simply do not count. Toulouse 1696 (P121) removes from the contest anyone who thrusts at the face out of malice and does not allow a hit made while holding the opponent's foil. The Prague ordinance of 1597 (P052) names not techniques but manner: fencers are not to leap at each other furiously ‘like peasants’.

28 passages from 12 towns, 1544–1775. Sorted by year. A “rule” is what the text orders or forbids; “recorded practice” is what it records as an event or a claim. The summaries are working summaries; the original wording behind the link decides.

  1. 1544Königsberg

    In the prize fight all evil, secret and hidden techniques and tricks are excluded, whatever their names.

    P396 · proklamácia rule edition read

    alle böse, heimliche, verborgene Stücke und Listen
  2. 1544Königsberg

    Whoever uses the forbidden techniques bears the risk and consequences himself.

    P396 · proklamácia rule edition read

    soll er seine Gefahr deshalb ausstehen
  3. c. 1568Augsburg

    Whoever in free fencing seizes his opponent's weapon, holds it and strikes him so is barred from the school for a year and also falls to the council's punishment.

    P046 · chytenie zbrane a úder rule edition read

    dem andern in freyem fechten sein wöhr ergriffe, Dieselbige halten, vnd also auf In schlagen wurde, Dem soll die Schul ain Jar lang verpotten
  4. c. 1568Augsburg

    Whoever strikes over, under or across a thrown pole (Stange) must lay down his weapon at once and may raise no weapon, short or long, at that school.

    P046 · úder cez tyč (Stange) rule edition read

    über, vnder oder fürgeworffne Stangen schlecht, Der soll alsbald one alle mittel von Stunden sein wöhr Niderlegen
  5. c. 1568Augsburg

    Neither local nor foreign fencers may fence with dishonest pieces (vnredlichen stucken) against the council's ordinance and the established custom of fencing.

    P046 · nepoctivé kusy rule edition read

    hieige oder frembde Fechter auf ainander Schul mit vnredlichen stucken Auch über hierInn begriffne aines Ersamen Raths alhie
  6. 1574Neuburg an der Donau

    Whoever strikes, jabs or throws with the cross or pommel, thrusts with the sword or strikes with a broken lance wins no prize.

    P403 · 10 rule original checked

    Da einer mit Creutz oder Knopff nach dem anderen schlagen
  7. 1574Neuburg an der Donau

    Whoever claps into the opponent's sword or catches his blows wins no prize.

    P403 · 12–13 rule original checked

    der dem andern in sein Schwerdt platzt
  8. after 1589Lille

    Entries and blows with the pommel and cross-guard have no value; only hits with the blade count.

    P013 · údery hlavicou a priečkou (zákaz) rule edition read

    toutes entrées et coups donnés du pommeau et croisure ne sera de valleur
  9. 1596Kassel

    Whoever breaks his lance on the barrier or touches the barrier with lance or sword before breaking it has no claim to a prize.

    P398 · 7 rule edition read

    die schrancken mit dem Spiesse vor dem brechen berühret
  10. 1596Kassel

    Whoever holds the sword with both fists at once or leans his hand on the barrier gets no prize; changing hands for a blow is permitted.

    P398 · 9 rule edition read

    Wer sein Schwert mit beyden feusten zu gleich brauchet
  11. 1596Kassel

    Whoever seizes or holds his opponent's sword and so catches his blows can win no prize that day.

    P398 · 13 rule edition read

    Wer dem andern in sein Schwert platzet oder helt
  12. 1597Prague

    Fencers are not to leap at each other furiously but to fence cleanly and deliberately according to the art, with every weapon.

    P052 · Kto sa neučil, nešermuje rule edition read

    nemají tak vztekle do sebe vskakovati, nýbrž čistě zdlouha podle umění té kratochvíle
  13. 1597Prague

    Every fencer must make the proper guard with each weapon according to the art, and not rush wildly at a weapon like a peasant to belabour his opponent.

    P052 · Riadne zdvihnutie zbrane rule edition read

    ne jako sedlák, aby střeštěně k zbrani běžel a ji do rukou popadna, vzal
  14. 1597Prague

    A pair fencing for money must not rush at each other like peasants with all their strength, but fence according to the art.

    P052 · Zápas o peniaze, bod 3 rule edition read

    nemají jako sedláci k sobě přikračovati na sebe vší mocí a silou
  15. 1601Tübingen

    It is forbidden to strike the opponent's pike out of his hands or to give ground once the fighters have engaged.

    P442 · V rule original checked

    Deßgleichen keiner weichen thun
  16. 1601Tübingen

    Whoever drops his sword or props himself on the barrier with it loses his claim to a prize; a broken sword is replaced.

    P442 · VI rule original checked

    Sein schwert würd fallen in den sand
  17. 1601Tübingen

    Whoever grabs into the opponent's sword loses the prize.

    P442 · X rule original checked

    Fellt oder greifft, den Danck verleurt
  18. 1601Tübingen

    The sword is wielded with one hand; a two-handed grip and blows with cross-guard and pommel are forbidden.

    P442 · XII rule original checked

    Mit Creutz und Knopff viel weniger
  19. 1614Wrocław

    All unseemly moves, especially the harmful cutting at the legs, pommel strikes, throwing down and striking over the staves, are forbidden on pain of severe punishment.

    P134 · odsek 2 (zakázané kusy) rule original checked

    sollen alle vnziemliche stücke, sonderlich aber das schedliche bein hauen, knopf stoßen, Niderwerffen, Vber die Stangen schlagen
  20. 1615Wrocław

    Improper moves are forbidden under severe penalty, in particular leg-cutting, pommel strikes, throwing down and striking over the pole.

    P114 · Zakázané kusy rule original checked

    das schädliche Beinhauen, Knopfstoßen, Niederwerffen, Vber die Stange schlagen
  21. 1616Ghent

    In the play for the kingship there may be no grip, thrust, hand laid on the sword or body-to-body rush; otherwise the hit is void for king and challenger alike.

    P063 · čl. X rule edition read

    sonder grepe, ofte steken, ofte een handt van het Zweirdt te doen
  22. 1616Ghent

    Whoever grips his opponent’s blade in the bout pays 2 groats.

    P063 · čl. XLVI rule edition read

    grypt den lemmer van synen Campioen
  23. 1696Toulouse

    A man who thrust at the face out of malice is to be removed from the contest for the prize.

    P121 · čl. 11 rule edition read

    à moins qu'on connut qu'un homme y poussât par malice, en ce cas il doit être tiré du Prix
  24. 1696Toulouse

    Hits made while holding the foil, thrust with two hands, or with the foil changed from hand to hand are not counted.

    P121 · čl. 17 rule edition read

    en tenant le Fleuret, ou qui sont poussez de deux mains, ou changeant le Fleuret de main, ne sont point comptez
  25. 1775Bordeaux

    A provost who teaches on his own without his master's knowledge and consent is barred from the mastership.

    P385 · čl. 16 rule edition read

    qui montreront eux-mêmes ledit art à l'inçu de leur Maître
  26. 1775Bordeaux

    A master who takes up a profession incompatible with the nobility of the art must close his hall and loses the mastership.

    P385 · čl. 45 rule edition read

    sera contraint sur le champ de fermer la salle
  27. Reims

    Whoever strikes his companion or gives him the lie pays 12 deniers.

    P023 · 13 rule edition read

    qui son compaignon frappera / Ou démentira
  28. Reims

    Whoever turns his back while playing pays one blanc.

    P023 · 20 rule edition read

    qui l'eschine tournera, quant il joura