Fencing Guild Sources
Page language · English

Themes › Valid hits and blood

Valid hits and blood

What counts as a hit: where it must land, whether the highest wound or blood decides, how many exchanges are played and who wins.

What the comparison shows

The German and Bohemian schools measure a hit by height and blood: the Strasbourg tournament of around 1470 (P006) gives the prize to whoever lands the most and the highest bloody hits, and the Prague ordinance of 1597 (P052) does not stop a bout for money at first blood and always prefers the higher wound to the lower.

The French and Flemish contests measure by the place on the body. In Lille (P013, P015) a hit counts above the belt and must leave a visible mark. In Toulouse 1696 (P121) the target runs from the belt to the neck between the shoulder seams, and a hit to the face is replayed. In Paris 1644 (P027) and in the Lille ‘kingdom of pleasure’ (P018) the hit nearest the heart decides; in Namur 1610 (P256) the highest hit nearest the point of the cap.

53 passages from 17 towns, 1470–1775. Sorted by year. A “rule” is what the text orders or forbids; “recorded practice” is what it records as an event or a claim. The summaries are working summaries; the original wording behind the link decides.

  1. 1470Strasbourg

    Masters are paired by lot and each pair fights only once; the one struck withdraws and another takes his place; the prize goes to whoever lands the most and highest bloody hits.

    P006 · § 2 rule edition read

    wer dann also díe meisten Vnd die höhsten blütrüre geton hett dem solt sín gobe gedihen
  2. 1470Strasbourg

    A scribe records the masters and pupils and also who lands the highest and cleanest bloody hits.

    P006 · § 9 rule edition read

    eínen schriber do zů haben díe meister und schůler anzůschriben vnd ouch wer die höhsten und fryesten blütrüre tüge
  3. 1470Strasbourg

    Whoever receives a hit need not be bound to continue the bouts unless he himself wishes (reading uncertain).

    P006 · § 11 rule edition read

    welhen ein Růre wurt der sol nit verbunden sin mit genge vůrün er tüge es dann gern
  4. 1491Frankfurt am Main

    Each master fences at least 2 or 3 passes (geng) with the candidate.

    P047 · Prijímanie nových majstrov rule original checked

    die Mayster sollen Auch Alle mit Ime Fechten Iglicher zum Minsten 2 Oder 3 geng
  5. 1495Baden (Aargau)

    Schwitzer will readily accept a challenge to fight for a free bloody wound, if the mayor and council allow.

    P311 · výzva recorded practice known from citation

    oder umb ein frye blůtrunsde rür zů fechten begerte
  6. 1530Amiens

    Of their three rounds the pupils may win only one of the hits, and may not hit one another while the master examines them; the fine is twelve deniers.

    P020 · čl. 26 rule edition read

    de leurs trois venues gaigner que l’une des touches, et se ne pourront toucher l’un l’autre pendant que le maistre les visete
  7. 1530Amiens

    In a prize game, if one player’s hit is disputed, the one whose hit is undisputed is preferred and wins the prize.

    P020 · čl. 28 rule edition read

    celluy qui aura sa touche sans débat sera préféré et gaignera ledit pris
  8. 1534Frankfurt am Main

    The candidate fences two passes with each challenger without refusal, and if he stands unharmed each master fences one pass with the sword with him.

    P047 · Poriadok 1534: verejné predstavenie rule original checked

    mit Einem Jeden zwen geng One Abschlag zu willen sein
  9. c. 1568Augsburg

    A fencer may not raise twice with one weapon unless he means to fence for the wreath.

    P046 · zdvíhanie s jednou zbraňou rule edition read

    mit ainer wöhr zwaymal nicht aufheben Er were dann willens vmb den krantz zufechten willens
  10. 1574Neuburg an der Donau

    Whoever is struck by a thrust or blow on an unprotected place receives no prize, except in the free fighting (Foli).

    P403 · 7 rule original checked

    Wo einer bloß gestossen oder geschlagen würde
  11. 1574Neuburg an der Donau

    Thrusts and blows beyond the set number are not counted, even if broken.

    P403 · 8 rule original checked

    alle stöß oder streich / die vber vorgemelte zahl beschehen
  12. 1575Frankfurt am Main

    According to the masters the candidate was not struck so as to count as a wound hindering his mastership, but only scratched, as the burgomaster himself found on inspection.

    P165 · položka 10.1: zásah recorded practice edition read

    Sintemahl er nicht also geschlagen, daß es vor eine Verwundung zuhalten od[er] ihne ahn der Meÿsterschafft hindern
  13. 1589Lille

    No one may deny a hit he has felt, on pain of a fine of 1 sou to the master.

    P003 · čl. 32 rule edition read

    Que nul ne pourra nier quand il se aura
  14. after 1589Lille

    The claimant to the kingship has three attempts (vennes) and must hit the defender above the belt; the hit must be shown by a trace or mark, and the defender is bound likewise.

    P013 · tri pokusy a zásah nad opaskom rule edition read

    sera tenu toucher le deffendeur par dessus la chainture
  15. after 1589Lille

    Entries and blows with the pommel and cross-guard have no value; only hits with the blade count.

    P013 · údery hlavicou a priečkou (platnosť) rule edition read

    toutes entrées et coups donnés du pommeau et croisure ne sera de valleur
  16. after 1589Lille

    If the defender drops his sword, the attacker may claim a hit at the collar seam by the shoulder, unless he had already scored a better hit, which he may then keep.

    P013 · pád meča obrancu rule edition read

    l'assaillan qui donneroit coup aura droit de toucher à la cousture du gorgerain vers l'épaule
  17. after 1589Lille

    If the defender falls to the ground, the attacker has the right to a free hit at the fold beneath the hat cord.

    P013 · pád obrancu na zem (zásah) rule edition read

    l'assaillant aura droit de touche franche au ply de dessoubs le cordon du chappeau
  18. after 1589Lille

    If the attacker drops his sword he loses the attempt begun and one more; if he himself falls to the ground he loses all right to fence.

    P013 · pád meča alebo pád útočníka rule edition read

    perdera la venne commenchée et une après ; et s'il tombait lui-même par terre perdera tout droit de tirer les armes
  19. after 1589Lille

    A hit above the belt is understood by the seam of the doublet, whether or not there is a belt; the belt stays where it was when the blow fell.

    P015 · výklad: nad opaskom rule edition read

    a esté résolu que ce s'entendroit de la cousture du pourpoint, soit qu'il y ait ceinture ou non
  20. after 1589Lille

    The hit must be visible; that it was felt does not count, since a hit by one's own guard or the opponent's guard has no value.

    P015 · výklad: viditeľný zásah rule edition read

    Se doit aussi exactement observer qu'il doit paraître de la touche, sans que puisse venir en considération de l'avoir bien sentu
  21. after 1589Lille

    The collar seam by the shoulder means the seam of the collar of the jacket or doublet immediately on the shoulder.

    P015 · výklad k VI. článku: šev golieru rule edition read

    s'entend la cousture du collet soit de la casacque ou pourpoint immédiatement sur l'espaule
  22. 1596Kassel

    No prize goes to one who breaks his lance not with a free thrust but by swinging or crossing it.

    P398 · 5 rule edition read

    der seinen Spieß nicht mit einem freyen stosse bricht
  23. 1596Kassel

    A blow with the flat of the sword does not count towards a prize.

    P398 · 12 rule edition read

    Wer mit dem Schwert mit der flache schlecht
  24. 1597Prague

    Those fencing for money fight three gangs (kank), not stopping after the first drawn blood; a higher wound always counts for more than a lower.

    P052 · Zápas o peniaze, bod 4 rule edition read

    nebo rána vyšší vždycky více platí, než nižší
  25. 1598–1647Lille

    The ‘little bird’ is fought with the sword alone and the hit nearest the heart decides, according to the articles of the good kingdom.

    P018 · kráľovstvo pre potešenie: zásah rule edition read

    se tire de l'espée seule à la touche plus proche du cœur
  26. 1598–1647Lille

    If the defender falls to the ground he is reckoned hit on the button.

    P018 · kráľovstvo pre potešenie: pád obrancu rule edition read

    si le deffendant tombait par terre sera reputé touché au bouton
  27. 1601Tübingen

    Each fighter has only three pike thrusts and five sword blows; blows beyond this number do not count towards the prize.

    P442 · III rule original checked

    Und nur fünff schläg mit dem Schwert thon
  28. 1601Tübingen

    A hit on the unprotected (?) is not honourable and does not count, except in the free fight (Folie).

    P442 · VIII rule original checked

    Doch ausserhalb der Folien
  29. 1607Prague

    Even if the candidate is hit, he is made master of the long sword if he also lands a blood-hit on his opponent.

    P039 · čl. 3 rule edition read

    Wann er gleich geschlagen wird, und er einem Andern auch steil Blutrührn schlägt
  30. 1610Namur

    The king is made by a stroke of the two-handed sword: the one who hits highest and nearest the point of the cap wins, without fraud.

    P256 · súťaž o kráľa: zásah rule text read

    au coulp d’espée à deux mains, et le plus hault touché et plus près du poinct du bonnet, le tout sans fraulde ny malengin
  31. 1616Ghent

    If either fencer’s sword or other weapon breaks, the exchange is void and must be replayed.

    P063 · čl. X rule edition read

    indien een van hun Slach-Zweirden, ofte ander Wapen brake
  32. 1616Ghent

    If the master fails to see a hit that bystanders saw, they must tell him before being asked; a hit played over is not counted, and whoever kept silent pays 20 groats.

    P063 · čl. XXIV rule edition read

    syn selve schuldig te kennen te geven aen den Meester
  33. 1616Ghent

    Prizes are won with a clean thrust or blow: with the sword only hits above the elbow and above the seams of the doublet count, with other weapons hits on the body within the breast seams and above.

    P063 · čl. XXXI rule edition read

    boven den helleboge ende boven de naeden van het Wambaes
  34. 1633Paris

    The trial continues until two clean thrusts (deux bottes franches) have been landed.

    P026 · čl. 6 (skúška a obojstranný zásah) rule edition read

    recommenceront jusques à la fin de deux bottes franches
  35. 1644Paris

    The prizes are awarded to those who, in the trial, hit the candidate closest to the heart.

    P027 · čl. 9 rule edition read

    pour les prix qui seront adiugez à ceux qui donneront en l'experimentant le plus proche du cœur
  36. 1644Paris

    The bout continues until one or the other has given or received two clean thrusts (bottes franches).

    P027 · čl. 10 rule edition read

    iusques à ce que l'vn ou l'autre ayent donné ou receu les deux bottes franches
  37. 1647Lille

    The kingdom of pleasure is fought with the thrust alone; cuts (estramaçon) are of no value and the attacker loses the attempt.

    P018 · poznámka z 12. 5. 1647: bodnutie rule edition read

    se tirera à l'Estocade seule et que tout coup d'estramason (sic) seront de nulle valeur
  38. 1696Toulouse

    To enter the candidates' number one must beat three opponents in a row, in the first three hits judged good.

    P121 · čl. 3 rule edition read

    il en faut battre trois à suite aux trois premieres bottes jugées bonnes
  39. 1696Toulouse

    Hits to front and back count from the top of the belt to the top of the neck and inside the shoulder seams; the belt sits a little over a foot below the chin.

    P121 · čl. 7 rule edition read

    depuis le dessus de la ceinture qu'on attache autour du corps jusqu'au haut du col & en dedans des coûtures des épaules
  40. 1696Toulouse

    After two each, the first to land a hit puts the other out.

    P121 · čl. 8 rule edition read

    le premier qui donne sort l'autre
  41. 1696Toulouse

    Two successive hits count only if they are marked in two places.

    P121 · čl. 9 rule edition read

    pourveu qu'il soit marqué en deux endroits
  42. 1696Toulouse

    Hits to the face are replayed.

    P121 · čl. 11 rule edition read

    Les coups du visage sont à refaire
  43. 1696Toulouse

    If one hits the face or below the mark and the other the body, the body hit counts.

    P121 · čl. 12 rule edition read

    l'un donnoit au visage ou sous la marque, & l'autre au corps, celui du corps est compté
  44. 1696Toulouse

    A man who lands a hit after parrying with the hand loses one hit for that hand-parry and cannot count his own hit.

    P121 · čl. 13 rule edition read

    il en perd une qui est celle de sa parade de main, sans qu'il puisse compter son coup
  45. 1696Toulouse

    If a man hits without being hit by opposing his left hand to the opponent's thrust, the hit is replayed.

    P121 · čl. 14 rule edition read

    le coup est à refaire, parce que sans cela ils auroient receu tous deux
  46. 1696Toulouse

    A hit is good if, in parrying, whipping or binding the foil, it is knocked down and the thrust follows without a pause.

    P121 · čl. 16 rule edition read

    on le fait tomber & qu'on pousse sans intervalle à l'un de ces mouvemens, le coup est bon
  47. 1696Toulouse

    Hits not claimed in time, or of which the opponent was warned, are not counted.

    P121 · čl. 18 rule edition read

    Les coups qui ne sont point demandez à tems, ou desquels on aura été averti, ne sont point comptez
  48. 1754Hamburg

    The fencer challenges another fencing master in all weapons to the first blood.

    P277 · Program 1 recorded practice text read

    in allen Gewehren, bis aufs Blut
  49. 1775Paris

    At the wall or in the assault no one may call out “I have touched”, on pain of 5 sols.

    P222 · čl. 13 rule edition read

    De dire, soit à la muraille ou à l'assaut, J'ai touché
  50. 1775Bordeaux

    Defeat in a trial bout is measured by three clean hits (bottes franches).

    P385 · čl. 24 rule edition read

    s'il est battu de trois bottes franches
  51. 1775Bordeaux

    The masters fix the number of clean hits a candidate must give his rivals to win.

    P385 · čl. 28 rule edition read

    le nombre des bottes franches que chacun devra donner
  52. Reims

    Whoever denies a hit that the master recognises and the company confirms pays one blanc.

    P023 · 24 rule edition read

    Et le maistre le cognoistra, et la compagnie le dirat
  53. Reims

    Whoever boasts of a hit he gave his companion pays one blanc.

    P023 · 25 rule edition read

    Et du coup se vantera